Redesigning Clinical Workflows to Return Joy to Patient Care
Sharpening the Saw to Prevent Burnout

Tag Archives: Management

Sharpening the Saw to Prevent Burnout

I hear it all the time, Doctors don’t have time for huddles or improvement events!”

Really??? Have you heard the story of Sharpening the Saw? It stresses the importance of taking the time to ensure your tools are at working as well as possible, so that you can be most effective in your work. It’s an important message for burned our physicians and the executives who lead their organizations. In fact, Steven Covey includes this as the Seventh Habit in his Seven Habits of Highly Effective People.

The Story of Sharpening the Saw

There are a variety of stories regarding Sharpening the Saw. Some describe a man walking in the forest who encounters a woodsman working furiously at sawing down a tree, but making little progress. Another describes a competition between two lumberjacks, one of whom immediately begins sawing down trees while the other takes time to first sharpen his saw. A third includes a quote attributed to Abraham Lincoln effectively saying, “If I had eight hours to chop down a tree, I’d spend the first six sharpening my axe.”

In each case, the work goes better and faster after “sharpening the saw”. The moral of the story is that we tend to favor being busy and working hard to achieve the task at hand rather than properly in order to work most effectively. We waste a lot of effort if our saw blade is dull. The time spent sharpening the saw is more than made up for because we are more efficient when the blade is sharp.

What Does Sharpening the Saw Have to Do with Burnout?

A root cause of burnout is putting a highly motivated professional into a work situation where success requires constant vigilance to fix barriers and frustrations. I describe this as a toxic workplace, because that constant vigilance is unsustainable and leads to burnout, and to high rates of physician depression, family dysfunction, substance abuse, and suicide.

The best way to fix this is not to provide physicians with resilience training to better cope with the toxicity, but to detoxify the workplace by fixing the defects and workflow problems that cause the frustration. This seems obvious. Yet most organizations struggle to find the time to do this improvement work, and doctors are often the last to join in and participate in improvement work.

Why is it Hard to Invest Time in Improvement?

We all know why. As things are now, we don’t have any spare time. Most of us are working 12 hour days, 70-80 hour weeks. And we still have significant access problems with delays of weeks or months for patients to get an appointment, or delays of many hours to be seen in the emergency department or get admitted to a hospital bed.

How can we possibly make someone wait longer so that we can take time for improvement work? For physicians, the thought of giving up 15 minutes for a huddle when we could have seen another patient, or worse yet give up a week for a kaizen-type redesign event, seems like it will only make things worse. Let others do improvement work. We physicians are too important for that! We have patients to see.

Ways Physicians Sharpen the Saw

Do you take time for vacation? Do you take time off for CME? Of course you do, or at least I hope you do. It’s important to take time off to replenish yourself, to regain inner energy. It’s important to ensure your knowledge and skills are current in order to provide your patients the best care possible.

Do you also take time to participate in daily huddles or occasional week-long workflow redesign events? If not, why not? If you are like most physicians, your days are filled with barriers and frustrations. Huddles can fix the small frustrations you encounter on a daily basis. Week-long improvement events can redesign work in ways you didn’t think possible, significantly improving your efficiency and giving you more capacity to focus on your patient.

In fact, if you don’t invest the time in huddles and improvement events, you are wasting the benefits of vacation and CME. You are not getting the full benefit from being rested after vacation or able to apply your new knowledge as effectively when your clinical workflows are still broken. And redesign may make things worse if physicians are not there to ensure your concerns are understood and your improvement ideas are included in the solution.

How Do You Find the Time for Improvement?

OK, so you know this is important, and yet it’s still hard to find the time. Change is hard. Doing it right takes:

  • Analysis of the situation to be sure you understand the issues and implications
  • Consensus building with key stakeholders, including your leaders, colleagues, and support staff, and
  • Experimentation to work out the bugs.

First, executive leaders need to commit to their physicians participating in huddles and events. This means protecting their time and income if they are on a productivity-based compensation model. Second, clinical leaders need to commit to organizing the huddles and events to be of true value to the physicians, prepping well and ensuring the focus stays on improving patient care. Third, physicians need to participate – raising their concerns about daily problems, and being engaged and present in the room during longer events.

Try It, You’ll Like It

I have yet to meet a physician who didn’t find value in participating in huddles and improvement events that are properly prepared and effectively run. In fact, most often physicians are surprised by how helpful these are, and become the strongest advocates among their colleagues.

My call to action, whether your are an executive, clinical leader, or front line physician, is to commit to making this happen. Why are we tolerating the waste of a physician’s skills, knowledge, and commitment when our clinical workflows are rife with barriers? We can fix this if we work together.

Make the time for improvement.

Sharpen your saw.

Decrease the need for constant vigilance, and increase the joy of working effectively, finding more time for your patients.

 

 

Executives – The Missing Stakeholders in Preventing Burnout

The National Academy of Medicine has launched an Action Collaborative on Clinician Well-Being and Resilience, but there is one missing stakeholder.  Last Friday, July 14th, NAM hosted it’s its first public meeting on establishing clinician well-being as a national priority. The inaugural sponsors include nearly many medical specialty societies, the major insurance companies, the American Associations… Continue Reading

Single Payer Solution to Burnout?

Is Single Payer the solution to burnout? I received an email from a good friend this week, Dr. Patty Gabow, who is CEO-emerita of Denver Health.  As CEO, Patty led a Lean transformation of Denver Health that achieved great physician and staff engagement while saving the State of Colorado over 200 million dollars.  She is… Continue Reading

Servant Leadership – Asking Questions, Not Giving Answers

Servant Leadership is alive and well among effective Lean leaders in Europe. This past week I had the good fortune to give a presentation on “Preventing Physician Burnout” at the 3rd Annual Lean Healthcare Transformation Summit Europe in Brussels.  It was a great meeting with 300+ attendees from 17 countries all committed to transforming health… Continue Reading

The Hamster Wheel – Shorthand for Physician Burnout

Using the burnout model of Maslach and Leiter, and relating it to a hamster wheel, and a busy physician, the impact of this analogy becomes clear. Lean Done Right is an effective way to address the problem. Continue Reading

Conflicting Values – Physician Burnout Driver Number Six

Today’s Posting on Conflicting Values is the sixth and final in my series on the drivers of physician burnout as described in The Truth About Burnout by Maslach and Leiter.  Physicians place great value in their ability to provide compassionate quality care to their patients.  Health system leaders similarly proclaim a dedication to compassion and… Continue Reading

Front Line Connections

Last Sunday I focused on the fifth driver of burnout – Absence of Fairness. Leaders can increase the sense of fairness with front line connections to caregivers by being present in the clinical areas to understand the challenges first hand.  Of course, rapidly solving problems is key to making people feel that they are being… Continue Reading

Breakdown of Community

Breakdown of Community results from the first three drivers of burnout. When people are overloaded, lack control, and receive insufficient reward, they begin to act in ways that protect themselves as individuals. Individual self-protection leads to Breakdown of Community. Continue Reading

VANCOUVER CLINIC: ENGAGING PHYSICIANS IN STRATEGY DEVELOPMENT

Each week for the next six weeks I will post a vignette from our book “Preventing Physician Burnout” that highlights actions leaders take to reduce the impact of physician burnout.  Here is the first, on engaging physicians in strategic planning as a way to connect vision and values… Engaging Physicians in Strategy Located in Washington… Continue Reading

4DX and Lean

As I coach executives in health care systems around the country, I’m hearing interest in 4DX and Lean. I’ve seen hospitals implement both, and spurred by the recent interest, I reread The 4 Disciplines of Execution by Sean Covey, Chris McChesney, and Jim Huling. It’s well written and compelling in the stories they share of… Continue Reading

Servant Leadership

How do you approach Servant Leadership?  Do you aspire to serve those you lead?    I’ve struggled a bit with what the concept of servant leadership truly implies. A servant’s master can command the servant to perform tasks that primarily further the master’s self interest.  If, as servant leaders, we must obey the physicians and staff no… Continue Reading